14
Nov
Posted by Mark Williams in General
Tom Short, the President of IATSE, has sent an open letter to Patric Verrone, the president of the Writers Guild West.

“Ever since late last year,” the letter begins, “when the WGAw announced withdrawal from its own proposed negotiating date in January 2007, I have warned you and predicted the devastation that would come from your actions. These predictions have now come true.”
Short then goes on to reference an LA Times story, noting that while the industry could be facing a loss of over $1 billion in the shutdown, the WGA’s chief negotiator, David Young “is quoted in the Times as delighted he’s being treated ‘like a rock star’ at rallies and says ‘I just look back at the havoc I’ve wreaked… I’m not going to apologize for that.’ This is hardly the point of view of a responsible labor leader.”
A bit of an understatement really, give the pain that crew people — caught in the crossfire — are already feeling. How is that wordsmiths choose a negotiator who so poorly manages his words?
Short continues, saying “the Times points out that Mr. Young has never negotiated a contract in the motion picture industry. His incompetence and inexperience are causing irreperable damage.”
And this is where Short connects the dots to the Bigger Picture in America today, as the fallout from the havoc-wreakers in the White House, and elsewhere, becomes evident. Short observes that the strike comes “at a time when we can ill afford to ignore the worsening national economy, the unstable international climate, and the crises in health care and the housing market that are affecting many of our working families.”
“When I phone you on Nov. 28, 2006 to ask you to reconsider the timing of negotiations, you refused.” Short concludes it was Young’s intention, all along, that there be a strike.
The letter notes that number of shows that have already been shuttered — over 50 — and conludes that “it’s time to put egos aside and recognize how crucial it is to get everyone back to work, before there is irreversible damage from which the industry can never recover.”
Short to neglects to mention his own IA members, however, who are currently striking against Broadway producers, and who have shuttered the Great White Way. But the stakes for the IA are even higher, here.
And his casting the situation in the larger context of a fragile, imploding world is commendable — even if he leaves out any analysis of the stakes for the multinationals that own the studios — and the “content.”

Still, real people are being hurt, in and out of the IA. And though we are not quite at Thanksgiving, perhaps Denis Leary’s “Merry fuckin’ Christmas” will be the theme du jour in L.A. this holiday season.
6 Responses
AMERICAN IA brother
November 15th, 2007 at 2:22 am
1Short also will tell you that run-away production to CANADA has NO effect what so ever on American workers ! He has opposed ANY effort to stem run-away production to government subsidized countries.
Short has NO credibility as a fighter for the AMERICAN film worker.
tony
November 16th, 2007 at 11:19 am
2Mr. Brother sir,
Hummm so you have nothing to say to Mr.Young’s narrow minded and selfish comment about being a rock star or the havoc he has created and seems to crave…that one comment is what irks people and many writers either cannot find fault with or for some odd reason see his behavior as totally happening and cool….Consider how this has settled into being about all those internet dollars…and then consider they (writers) cannot grasp how such a thoughtless, lame, ignorant, selfish statement rings in the heads of all the people put out of work over their strike…hey NEWSFLASH…if you guys are SO creative, brilliant, deserving maybe show us you can REALLY come up with a way to lead us to believe your actions are just instead of that bullhorn you guys are latched onto saying such bizzare things with a bozo like that the studios need not bother tossing dirt, lies or much else…fact is the longer this goes on the less (as in lots) sympathy writers will get from the people they work with
705 member
November 17th, 2007 at 2:57 pm
3Mr. Short, All we’ve been hearing is we all have to be reasonable. Runaway production will hurt us, striking will hurt us, blah blah blah. As Union members we have to wake up and look at our brothers and sisters in the automotive industry, textiles, steel, manufacturing, etc. to know that compromise is a losing proposition. Unions equal solidarity.
Non-strike clauses in our contracts is harmful and unamerican. As we unite we have strength. With Strength we have results. Ordering members not to honor our fellow Union members right to strike is dangerous. And it sends a message to our government that fear works in the union world.
tony
November 18th, 2007 at 12:55 pm
4Dear Mr. 706,
The comparison to striking lets say GM is not fair, nor is the lame comparison some have made to the civil rights causes of before. This strike (maybe your stirke) isn not about equal rights but money comparing your strike to people fighting and dying to be treated like equals is plain and simple disgusting…as for comparing to lets say striking GM or a coal mine…the UAW goes on strike and its membership encompasses most of the work force you guys (writers) go on strike and the coat tail effect drags along everyone….what you and your members see as strength others feel as unnessicary pain and that lack of compassion or even inability to address that is what will eventually drag you down and cause anger and resentment that will last for years.
If the current talks fail and there is a counter demonstration it will not be about solidarity it will be about showing you and your membership something, it would be sad if writers were so dim witted to see the counter demonstration as a show of solidarity and show up to march along side but hey dumber things have happened right?
Mark
November 18th, 2007 at 5:27 pm
5Tony–
Would it be possible for you to tell us firsthand, about your own experiences in/with the strike?
Did you work on a show that was shuttered? etc.
This might be constructive for the conversation here…
–Mark
tony
November 19th, 2007 at 12:11 pm
6Mark,
Hummm lets see as noted this town has tendency to have a very long memory and clings to either real or imagined insults or transgressions with no time limits. It would be to say the least foolish of me to even use my own name and maybe as foolish to give any clues as to where I could be.
Its safe to say my job places me in a interesting place to collect information and opinions. One thing I have learned about Hollywood is people do not openly share opinions but if they can or feel someone is listening is amazing what people will tell me.
As for shuttered shows that something anyone even remotely close to the industry could find-perhaps a list here would shock people. More to the point are the ordinary people to be met and spoken with throughout Burbank or sitting at home bored, worried and not very happy.
As for constructive if you mean some sort of possible solution…sure but it would have occured well before this strike was called and it would seem that the union really did not care about what the public or their fellow entertainment industry workers felt, thought or would endure, now that the strike is on it seems odd they are acting as if solidarity is something to be EXPECTED…My idea would be to backtrack, reach out and somehow make their cause something public opinion (fellow industry emplyees) could relate to and enbrace once that is done they could truely put pressure on the large corporations that own the studios to do as they want….pickets and demonstrations serve no point if you have no attention or support
RSS feed for comments on this post
Leave a reply
Calendar
Categories
Archives
Meta